Ballot Measure 11

The Oregon Criminal Justice Commission recently released a controversial report regarding Ballot Measure 11, a citizens' initiative establishing mandatory minimum sentences for certain felony person crimes.  Oregon voters approved the ballot in November, 1994.  BM 11 applies to all criminal defendants, ages 15 and up, which means juveniles who are at least 15 years old, are tried as adults for certain crimes.  Person crimes falling under BM 11 include Assault, Robbery, Sodomy and Manslaughter.  Those sentenced under BM 11 are ineligible for probation, parole and early release from prison.

Proponents of the Measure felt that judges were being too lenient when it came to sentencing of violent offenders.  While the opposition felt judges should use their discretion when sentencing individuals.

In it's Report, the Criminal Justice Commission found that the Measure has shifted power to the prosecutors, by giving them the upperhand in plea negotiations involving lesser crimes.  The Commision further concluded that BM 11 hasn't worked.  However, prosecutors and many victims' rights advocates believe BM 11 is an effective tool and has drastically reduced violent crimes.

I am curious to hear what you, the general public, think of BM 11.  Is it effective?  Should it be abolished?  Let's hear what you think...